Skip to primary navigation Skip to content Skip to footer
Back to BLOG

Discovering the Hidden Gem: The History of Water Island, US Virgin Islands

Nestled in the Caribbean Sea, the US Virgin Islands offer an array of picturesque destinations. While St. Thomas and St. John are widely known, there is a hidden gem awaiting discovery: Water Island. Despite its small size, this charming island holds a rich history that has shaped its identity over the centuries. Join us as we delve into the fascinating past of Water Island, uncovering tales of pirates, Danish colonization, and its transformation into a beloved tropical paradise.

A Pirate’s Haven

Water Island’s history can be traced back to the 17th century when pirates sought refuge in the Virgin Islands’ strategic hideouts. With its secluded coves and natural harbors, the island provided a safe haven for notorious buccaneers such as Blackbeard and Bluebeard. Legend has it that hidden treasure still lies buried beneath its sandy shores, tempting adventurers to this day.


a boat in the water

Dinghy’s Beach Bar on Water Island


Danish Colonization 

In the 17th century, the Danish West India Company established its presence in the Virgin Islands, including Water Island. They recognized the island’s potential as a strategic vantage point and named it “Carolina Island.” The Danes utilized the island for agricultural purposes, particularly for growing cotton, sugar cane, and indigo. The remnants of old plantations and ruins stand as a testament to this era.

The Transfer of the Virgin Islands 

In 1917, the United States purchased the Danish West Indies, which included Water Island. The strategic significance of the islands became apparent during World War II, leading to the construction of Fort Segarra on Water Island. This fort served as a coastal defense station until the late 1940s. Today, it stands as a historical landmark and offers breathtaking panoramic views of the surrounding islands.

Transformation into a Residential Haven 

Following its military use, Water Island underwent significant development and transformation into a residential community. Its natural beauty, serene beaches, and proximity to St. Thomas attracted individuals seeking a peaceful island lifestyle. The island boasts a tight-knit community, with a population of around 200 residents who cherish the island’s tranquility and picturesque landscapes.

A Tropical Paradise 

Water Island has evolved into a tropical paradise that captivates visitors with its unspoiled beaches, lush vegetation, and crystal-clear waters. With its pristine coastline, popular beaches like Honeymoon Beach and Limestone Beach offer idyllic settings for relaxation and water sports. Visitors can explore the underwater world through snorkeling and diving or embark on hiking trails that showcase the island’s natural beauty.

water next to the ocean

Aerial photo of Water Island, USVI


Water Island, the hidden gem of the US Virgin Islands, has a vibrant history that has shaped its unique character. From pirate hideout to Danish colony and then a residential haven, this tiny island is a testament to the dynamic past of the Caribbean. Today, Water Island welcomes visitors to bask in its beauty, creating memories while celebrating its rich historical heritage.